clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

These are best players that were Cardinals for one season (and one season only) - A Hunt and Peck

Take a guess...

St. Louis Cardinals v Cincinnati Reds Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images

Royals Review recently published a post about the best one-and-done seasons in Royals history. It looked like fun so I thought I would give it a whirl for the St. Louis Cardinals. To be thorough I went to Fangraphs and exported a data set with every player for the Cardinals. Then I filtered out all the batters that appeared in over 162 games and pitchers that made more than 80 games, then sorted the remaining players by fWAR. I manually checked each player to make sure they only appeared in one season for the Cardinals — no partial seasons are sneaking in here! Here are the players I found...

6. Tony Womack, 2004 — 2.8 fWAR

Tony Womach bee-bopped around the league — his walk-off single off Cardinals’ Steve Kline in the playoffs advanced the Diamondbacks to the NLCS in 2001 and he tied the game against the Yankees in Game 7 of the World Series, setting of Luis Gonzalez game-winning hit off Marinao Rivera. In 2003 he was traded around to two teams before signing with Cardinals in 2004. It was a bounce-back season for Womack. He hit for .307/.349/.385, stole 26 bases, and played solid defense at second base and was a solid part of the Cardinals record setting 105-win club in 2004.

5. Mark Grudzielanek, 2005 — 2.8 fWAR

After Womack’s departure the Cardinals were once again in need of a second baseman. Enter Mark Grudzielanek. During his time with the club he batted .294/.334/.407 for a 96 wRC+ and hit for the cycle (I was at that game!).

4. Dick Allen, 1970 — 2.9 fWAR

After many years with the Phillies Dick Allen signed with the Cardinals in 1970 for one season. He split time between first and third base and put up a 142 wRC+ in 122 games with the club.

3. Ron Reed, 1975 — 4.5 fWAR

Ron Reed spent half a season with the Cardinals in 1975 after spending nine seasons with the Braves. He ended up with a career year that season, amassing 6.9 fWAR total and 4.5 for the Cardinals in 175.2 innings with a 3.23 ERA.

2. John McGraw, 1900 — 5.4 fWAR

John McGraw spent nine seasons with the Orioles before becoming a Cardinal in 1900. In 99 games he hit for .344/.505/.416 for a 161 wRC+. The third baseman was known for his toughness and his mouth. He would become a successful manager and is featured in many books.

1. Jason Heyward, 2015 — 5.6 fWAR

You might have guessed it, but Jason Heyward tops the Cardinals list of best one-and-done players. After a career year in 2015 with the Cardinals in which Heyward hit for .293/.359/.439 for a career high 121 wRC+ and career high 26 defensive runs saved Heyward signed an eight-year deal worth $184 million with the Chicago Cubs.

what else is going on in baseball...

The Last Time We Saw That Guy: Ken Griffey Jr. | FanGraphs Baseball

COVID-19 Roundup: Baseball in July? | FanGraphs Baseball

Manny Ramirez Is Eying a Return to Taiwan | FanGraphs Baseball

Finding the Sweet Spot in the MLB Season Proposal Chaos | FanGraphs Baseball

Get to Know the KBO, Part One | FanGraphs Baseball

The Worst Yankees of all time according to WAR | Pinstripe Alley

The minor league baseball season might be about to be cancelled Bleed Cubbie Blue

what the cardinals are up to...


the nl central

An exclusive interview with the simCubs manager | Bleed Cubbie Blue

viva el stuff...

The uniforms that inspired the name ‘Cardinals’ | Viva El Birdos

other things...

Inside the heartwarming world of Hot Wheels collecting |

We got the greatest simulated video game ending ever with our upstart college basketball team |

Tweet or e-mail me link @lil_scooter93 or at lil_scooter93 AT msn DOT com!