clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Having 13 pitchers on the roster is hurting the Cardinals - A Hunt and Peck

The extra pitcher is not necessary...

St Louis Cardinals Photo Day Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images

Let us all take trip back to around this time a year ago. Jose Martinez was playing terrific baseball in Spring Training, seemingly out of no where (though our very own Josey Curtis had always been high on him). It seemed he was destined to make the roster in 2017. Martinez did make the roster of course, but it happened at a cost: sending Tommy Pham to AAA Memphis.

See, there was no room on the roster for both Pham and Martinez. After the eight starters, the Cardinals were left with four spots on the bench for position players. One spot was filled by the backup catcher. One spot went to Matt Adams, the Cardinals “big left-handed bat”. One of the spots needed to go to a backup infielder, so Greg Garcia earned that spot. This left one remaining.

The Cardinals chose Martinez. It was not a bad choice - Martinez played really well. The problem was and is that it was a choice the Cardinals never actually needed to make. There was a way both Pham and Martinez could have made the team. The Cardinals insistence on carrying thirteen pitchers, something most teams do not do, limited the number of position players the team could carry. So to Memphis Pham went.

You might remember that after he came back up Tommy Pham went on to be the most valuable player on the team in 2017.

History could be repeating itself in 2018. Not with Tommy Pham, as he appears to have cemented his place on the big league roster. This year the odd man out might be Yairo Munoz. The infielder is having a fantastic spring, but it seems likely he will lose out to Harrison Bader for a roster spot as the Cardinals are looking for another outfielder. Of course, if the Cardinals did not intend to carry thirteen pitchers, there would be room for both.

Oh well.

Munoz continues to make his case for Cards roster spot | St. Louis Cardinals |

what else is going on in baseball...

Neil Walker is where he belongs, finally |

The Phillies signed Jake Arrieta and are now a popular playoff ‘sleeper’ |

There’s Always a Catch | FanGraphs Baseball

The Opt-Out Clause Is Evolving | FanGraphs Baseball

The Things You See in the Eighth Inning of a Spring Game | FanGraphs Baseball

The Most and Least Confident of Projections | FanGraphs Baseball

How Tax Reform Impacts Baseball | FanGraphs Baseball

Reporter 'Jim Buchanan,' AKA Joe Kelly, made his on-camera debut and he's a natural |

Twins excited about signing of Lance Lynn |

Jake Arrieta inked a heartfelt letter to the city of Chicago after signing with the Phillies |

Most indispensable players for 30 MLB teams |

Lance McCullers' greatest fear after giving up a homer to Yoenis Cespedes? Being made into a GIF |

Ichiro says wearing Mariners uni was 'special' |

Phillies sign Cy Young winner Jake Arrieta |

what the cardinals are up to...

Matt Carpenter Excels at Leadoff. What Happens If He Moves and Changes His Approach? |

Norris on course for duty in Cardinals bullpen | St. Louis Cardinals |

Ortiz: Cards prospect Gomber isn't flashy, just successful | Jose de Jesus Ortiz |

BenFred: When should we worry about this Cardinals offense? | Ben Frederickson |


the nl central

Let’s Talk About the Brewers’ Mediocre Projection | FanGraphs Baseball

Joey Votto messed with some fans after dropping a foul ball |

Joey Votto loves hitting so much he was practicing his swing while on first base |

Tweet or e-mail me links @lil_scooter93 or at lil_scooter93 AT msn DOT com!