For the weekend, a person sure to get plenty of responses. I'd say he's polarizing, but that would mean people were on the extremes on both sides.
You don't have to look far for reasons to downgrade, whether it's the defense or his general reputation for uncouthness (as symbolized by his famous WS trophy picture). He also, though, has a power lefty bat and has occasionally carried the team.
0? 100? In between? Cast your vote and remember the totals are up here.