I don't know if this has been done before, but around my area in Illinois we like to play the game all-time all-star cardinals team. The concept is pretty simple, you fill out your starting lineup, add two bench players, a entire pitching roatation, and a closer. The other rule is Stan Musial can only play one postion, so no Stan in right, left, and first. So haveing said all this I'll start.
1b-Stan the Man-simply the best
2b-Rodgers "Raja" Hornsby
c-Ted "Simba" Simmons
So as you can see you can use active players as well. I'm not going to specife if this is single season or career, lets just let that be part of the fun.